Roof Repair vs Replacement: How to Decide (Without Guessing)
Composite & PVC (Trex®, TimberTech®, Fiberon®) • Pressure-Treated & Cedar • Resurfacing • Railings • Lighting • Structural Repairs • Permits & HOA
Roof Repair vs Replacement: How to Decide (Without Guessing)
Need a fast inspection or a clear price range? Get a same-day callback when available.
Serving North Jersey • Licensed & insured • Financing options available
Roof Repair vs Replacement: How to Decide (Without Guessing) is written for homeowners across North Jersey who want straight answers—pricing, timelines, materials, and what to do in an emergency.
If you’re dealing with a leak or storm damage, call Terra Nova Construction for a fast inspection and a clear plan.
Service Area Map
We serve North Jersey and nearby towns. If you’re outside the map area, text us—chances are we still cover you.
Service Area Map
We serve North Jersey and nearby towns. If you’re outside the map area, text us—chances are we still cover you.
Service-area quick links
Looking for a contractor near you? Here are popular service pages:
Frequently asked questions (expand to read)
Do I need a new roof or just repairs?
It depends on your roof design and what we find during inspection. We’ll explain the cause, options, and the pros/cons so you can choose the right fix—without guesswork.
How do I know if I need a new roof?
It depends on your roof design and what we find during inspection. We’ll explain the cause, options, and the pros/cons so you can choose the right fix—without guesswork.
What are signs I need roof replacement?
It depends on your roof design and what we find during inspection. We’ll explain the cause, options, and the pros/cons so you can choose the right fix—without guesswork.
Can my roof be repaired instead of replaced?
It depends on your roof design and what we find during inspection. We’ll explain the cause, options, and the pros/cons so you can choose the right fix—without guesswork.
Is a patch a permanent solution?
It depends on your roof design and what we find during inspection. We’ll explain the cause, options, and the pros/cons so you can choose the right fix—without guesswork.
How many repairs until I need replacement?
It depends on your roof design and what we find during inspection. We’ll explain the cause, options, and the pros/cons so you can choose the right fix—without guesswork.
My roof is 20 years old – should I replace it?
It depends on your roof design and what we find during inspection. We’ll explain the cause, options, and the pros/cons so you can choose the right fix—without guesswork.
How many layers of shingles can I have?
It depends on your roof design and what we find during inspection. We’ll explain the cause, options, and the pros/cons so you can choose the right fix—without guesswork.
What if there’s decking damage?
It depends on your roof design and what we find during inspection. We’ll explain the cause, options, and the pros/cons so you can choose the right fix—without guesswork.
Should I replace gutters when replacing roof?
It depends on your roof design and what we find during inspection. We’ll explain the cause, options, and the pros/cons so you can choose the right fix—without guesswork.
Why are my shingles curling/cracking?
It depends on your roof design and what we find during inspection. We’ll explain the cause, options, and the pros/cons so you can choose the right fix—without guesswork.
What are those black streaks on my roof?
It depends on your roof design and what we find during inspection. We’ll explain the cause, options, and the pros/cons so you can choose the right fix—without guesswork.
Why are shingles missing?
It depends on your roof design and what we find during inspection. We’ll explain the cause, options, and the pros/cons so you can choose the right fix—without guesswork.
There are granules in my gutters – is this bad?
It depends on your roof design and what we find during inspection. We’ll explain the cause, options, and the pros/cons so you can choose the right fix—without guesswork.
My roof is sagging – what does this mean?
It depends on your roof design and what we find during inspection. We’ll explain the cause, options, and the pros/cons so you can choose the right fix—without guesswork.
What are ice dams and how do I prevent them?
It depends on your roof design and what we find during inspection. We’ll explain the cause, options, and the pros/cons so you can choose the right fix—without guesswork.
Why is there moss on my roof?
It depends on your roof design and what we find during inspection. We’ll explain the cause, options, and the pros/cons so you can choose the right fix—without guesswork.
My chimney flashing is rusted – can you fix it?
It depends on your roof design and what we find during inspection. We’ll explain the cause, options, and the pros/cons so you can choose the right fix—without guesswork.
What are those rubber boots around pipes?
It depends on your roof design and what we find during inspection. We’ll explain the cause, options, and the pros/cons so you can choose the right fix—without guesswork.
Should I have ridge vents installed?
It depends on your roof design and what we find during inspection. We’ll explain the cause, options, and the pros/cons so you can choose the right fix—without guesswork.
Do I need more attic ventilation?
It depends on your roof design and what we find during inspection. We’ll explain the cause, options, and the pros/cons so you can choose the right fix—without guesswork.
What are soffit vents and do I need them?
It depends on your roof design and what we find during inspection. We’ll explain the cause, options, and the pros/cons so you can choose the right fix—without guesswork.
Why is my roof deck soft/spongy?
It depends on your roof design and what we find during inspection. We’ll explain the cause, options, and the pros/cons so you can choose the right fix—without guesswork.
What’s causing my high energy bills?
It depends on your roof design and what we find during inspection. We’ll explain the cause, options, and the pros/cons so you can choose the right fix—without guesswork.
Should I add more insulation when replacing roof?
It depends on your roof design and what we find during inspection. We’ll explain the cause, options, and the pros/cons so you can choose the right fix—without guesswork.
Tip: If you’re unsure whether you need repair or replacement, start with an inspection—then decide with real data.
Get a roof inspection & clear plan
If you need roof repair, emergency tarping, or a full replacement, we’ll inspect, document, and explain options in plain language.
Call now: 973-510-2585
Get a Free Estimate
Tell us what you need (roofing, windows, siding, gutters, soffit/fascia). We’ll confirm pricing and scheduling.