New Roof Leaking After Replacement? What to Do in NJ
You just paid for a new roof and now there's water in the house. It's frustrating, and it usually has a clear cause: a detail that was reused, skipped or rushed. Here's what commonly makes a new roof leak, what to do first, and how to get it fixed whether or not the original roofer comes back.
Licensed & insured • NJ Lic. #13VH13824700 • Locally owned in Garfield, NJ • Free on-site inspections • Hablamos español
Text photos of the leak and the roof to 973-200-1617 for a second look.
- ✓ Same-day appointments often available
- ✓ Licensed & insured in NJ
- ✓ Homes & businesses
- ✓ English & Español
Why is my new roof leaking?
A new roof that leaks usually has a problem at a detail, not the shingles: old flashing reused at a chimney or wall, a missed or cracked pipe boot, a valley done wrong, nails placed too high or exposed, or no ice & water barrier at the eaves. In winter, what looks like a new-roof leak can also be attic condensation from poor ventilation. Document the leak with dated photos, notify your roofer in writing so the workmanship warranty applies, and get the source found before it damages the ceiling and insulation. If you need a second opinion, Terra Nova Roofing & Construction offers a free on-site inspection with photos. Call or text 973-200-1617.
What to do first when a new roof leaks
Protect the inside
Bucket under the drip, move furniture and electronics, and keep people away from a bulging ceiling.
Document everything
Dated photos and video of the leak, the ceiling and the weather. Keep your contract, invoice and any warranty papers together.
Notify the roofer in writing
Text or email so there's a record. Most workmanship warranties require you to report problems and give the installer a chance to fix them.
Don't let anyone else touch it yet
If the original roofer is responsive, let them fix it first so you don't affect their warranty. If they're not, get a written second opinion.
For an active leak during a storm, a temporary dry-in or tarp protects the house while the warranty question is sorted out. See emergency roof tarping.
Why new roofs leak: the most common causes
| Cause | What happened | Where it shows |
|---|---|---|
| Reused flashing | Old chimney, wall or skylight flashing left in place and caulked | Ceiling near the chimney, dormer or skylight |
| Pipe boot missed or damaged | Old boot reused, or a new one cracked or not sealed | Bathroom or kitchen ceiling under a vent |
| Valley mistakes | Shingles cut wrong, no barrier under the valley | Inside corners of the house |
| Nailing errors | Nails too high, exposed or missing the deck | Random spots, often after wind |
| No ice & water barrier | Barrier skipped at eaves and valleys | Exterior walls, mostly in winter |
| Step flashing skipped | Roof-to-wall joints sealed with caulk only | Walls under dormers or second-floor walls |
| Deck damage covered over | Soft or rotted wood not replaced | Sagging spots, nails that won't hold |
| Gutter or drip edge problems | Water running behind the gutter | Fascia, soffit and the top of exterior walls |
Most of these come down to one thing: details that need time and care were treated like an afterthought.
Is it a leak, or is it condensation?
In a New Jersey winter, many "new roof leaks" are actually condensation. Warm, moist air from the house rises into a cold attic, frosts on the nails and underside of the deck, then melts and drips on the first warm day.
- Condensation signs: drips on sunny days after a cold spell, frost on nail tips, wet insulation spread across the attic, no link to rain.
- Leak signs: drips during or right after rain, a water trail from one spot, stains in one area.
A new roof can make condensation show up if the old one leaked air through gaps and the new one doesn't have enough ventilation. The fix is balanced ridge and soffit ventilation and sealing air leaks from the house, not more shingles. See roof leak or attic condensation and roof ventilation.
If your roofer won't come back
Most roofers want to fix their own work. When they don't answer:
- Send a dated written notice by email and text describing the leak, with photos, and keep a copy.
- Read your contract and warranty for how claims have to be made.
- If the shingles carry a manufacturer warranty, contact the manufacturer; registered warranties may have their own claim process.
- For a contractor dispute, the New Jersey Division of Consumer Affairs handles complaints about home improvement contractors.
- Get a written inspection with photos from another licensed roofer so you know exactly what's wrong.
We can inspect and document what we find, then give you a written estimate to fix it. Keep in mind that once another contractor repairs the roof, the original installer's workmanship warranty may no longer apply to that area.
Workmanship warranty vs. manufacturer warranty
A new roof usually has two kinds of coverage:
- Manufacturer warranty covers defects in the shingles or materials. It generally doesn't cover installation mistakes.
- Workmanship warranty comes from the contractor and covers how the roof was installed. Most new-roof leaks fall here.
Ask your roofer for both in writing. Terra Nova gives a workmanship guarantee on every job and registers the manufacturer warranty where it applies. More: roof warranties explained.
How Terra Nova finds and fixes a new-roof leak
Free inspection, inside and out
We check the attic for water trails, frost or wet insulation, then walk the roof at every flashing, boot and valley.
Photos and a written report
You see exactly what's wrong, useful for your original roofer, the manufacturer or a complaint.
Fix the detail properly
New step and counter flashing, new boots, rebuilt valleys or barrier added where it was skipped.
Exact price first
You get the price in writing before any work. Rotted decking or hidden damage is priced separately.
Hard-to-find or flat-roof leaks can be traced with a thermal roof scan, a paid service quoted up front. See thermal roof scan leak detection.
How to avoid a leaking new roof
Before you sign for a roof replacement, ask:
- Will you tear off to the deck and replace rotted wood?
- Is new flashing included at chimneys, walls and skylights, or is the old flashing reused?
- Are new pipe boots included?
- Where does ice & water barrier go?
- How will ventilation be handled?
- What workmanship guarantee do you give, in writing?
Terra Nova tears every roof off to the deck and installs synthetic underlayment, ice & water barrier and new flashing to manufacturer specs. Compare proposals line by line: how to compare roofing proposals and roof estimate checklist.
What homeowners say about us
★★★★★ 5-star rated on Google
Get a Free Second-Opinion Inspection
Tell us when the roof was replaced and where it's leaking. We'll find the cause, photograph it and give you a written estimate.
Why homeowners call us about new roofs
- New roof leaking within months
- Original roofer won't return calls
- Leak near the chimney or a wall
- Winter drips after a new roof
- Need photos for a warranty claim
Request your free estimate
Fill this out and a member of our team will follow up within one business day.
✓ No-obligation quote · ✓ Licensed & insured · ✓ Your info is never shared
Questions About a New Roof That Leaks
Is it normal for a new roof to leak?
No. A properly installed new roof shouldn't leak. When it does, it's usually a flashing, pipe boot, valley, nailing or barrier problem.
What should I do if my new roof is leaking?
Protect the inside, take dated photos, notify your roofer in writing and let them fix it under their workmanship warranty if they respond.
What if my roofer won't come back to fix the leak?
Send written notice, check your contract and warranty, contact the manufacturer if it applies and get a written inspection from another licensed roofer. Contractor complaints in New Jersey go to the Division of Consumer Affairs.
Will a second roofer void my warranty?
Repairs by another contractor may affect the original installer's workmanship warranty for that area. Give the original roofer a chance first if they're responsive.
Can a new roof cause condensation in the attic?
It can show up after a new roof if ventilation isn't balanced. Frost on nails and drips on sunny winter days point to condensation, not a leak.
Does the shingle warranty cover leaks?
Manufacturer warranties generally cover material defects. Most leaks on a new roof are installation issues covered, if at all, by the workmanship warranty.
Is the inspection free?
Yes. The on-site inspection and written estimate with photos are free.
How much does it cost to fix a leak on a new roof?
Roof leak repair starts from $650 and standard roof repair from $950. Emergency service starts from $1,500. Hidden damage is extra.
Do you replace old flashing when you put on a new roof?
Yes. Every Terra Nova replacement is torn off to the deck with new flashing, synthetic underlayment and ice & water barrier.
Are you licensed?
Yes. Terra Nova Roofing & Construction is licensed and insured, NJ Lic. #13VH13824700, locally owned in Garfield, NJ.
¿Hablan español?
Sí, hablamos español. Llame o mande texto al 973-200-1617.
Our service area
Bergen County
973-200-1617- Allendale
- Bergenfield
- Bogota
- Carlstadt
- Cliffside Park
- Closter
- Cresskill
- Demarest
- Dumont
- East Rutherford
- Edgewater
- Elmwood Park
- Emerson
- Englewood
- Englewood Cliffs
- Fair Lawn
- Fairview
- Fort Lee
- Franklin Lakes
- Garfield
- Glen Rock
- Hackensack
- Harrington Park
- Hasbrouck Heights
- Haworth
- Hillsdale
- Ho-Ho-Kus
- Leonia
- Little Ferry
- Lodi
- Lyndhurst
- Mahwah
- Maywood
- Midland Park
- Montvale
- Moonachie
- New Milford
- North Arlington
- Northvale
- Norwood
- Oakland
- Old Tappan
- Oradell
- Palisades Park
- Paramus
- Park Ridge
- Ramsey
- Ridgefield
- Ridgefield Park
- Ridgewood
- River Edge
- River Vale
- Rochelle Park
- Rutherford
- Saddle Brook
- Saddle River
- South Hackensack
- Teaneck
- Tenafly
- Teterboro
- Upper Saddle River
- Waldwick
- Wallington
- Washington Township
- Westwood
- Woodcliff Lake
- Wood-Ridge
- Wyckoff
Passaic County
973-200-1617- Bloomingdale
- Clifton
- Haledon
- Hawthorne
- Little Falls
- North Haledon
- Passaic
- Paterson
- Pompton Lakes
- Prospect Park
- Ringwood
- Totowa
- Wanaque
- Wayne
- West Milford
- Woodland Park
Essex County
973-200-1617- Belleville
- Bloomfield
- Caldwell
- Cedar Grove
- East Orange
- Essex Fells
- Fairfield
- Glen Ridge
- Irvington
- Livingston
- Maplewood
- Millburn
- Montclair
- Newark
- North Caldwell
- Nutley
- Orange
- Roseland
- Short Hills
- South Orange
- Verona
- West Caldwell
- West Orange
Hudson County
973-200-1617Union County
973-200-1617- Berkeley Heights
- Clark
- Cranford
- Elizabeth
- Fanwood
- Garwood
- Hillside
- Kenilworth
- Linden
- Mountainside
- New Providence
- Plainfield
- Rahway
- Roselle
- Roselle Park
- Scotch Plains
- Springfield
- Summit
- Union
- Westfield
Morris County
973-200-1617Updated November 2026 by the Terra Nova Roofing & Construction team, Garfield, NJ • NJ Lic. #13VH13824700

