Roof Underlayment Guide: Synthetic vs. Felt, Ice Barrier and Common Mistakes
Underlayment is the layer you never see and the one that saves the house when wind or ice gets under the shingles. This guide explains what roof underlayment does, synthetic vs. felt, where ice & water barrier belongs, how vapor barriers and house wrap fit in, and the installation mistakes that cause leaks on new roofs.
Licensed & insured • NJ Lic. #13VH13824700 • Locally owned in Garfield, NJ • Free on-site inspections • Hablamos español
Getting roof quotes? Text them to 973-200-1617 and we'll tell you what underlayment they include.
- ✓ Same-day appointments often available
- ✓ Licensed & insured in NJ
- ✓ Homes & businesses
- ✓ English & Español
What is roof underlayment and do I need it?
Roof underlayment is a water-resistant layer installed over the roof deck under the shingles. Shingles shed most of the water, but wind-driven rain and ice dams can push water under them, and the underlayment is what keeps that water off the wood. Every shingle roof needs it, along with self-sealing ice & water barrier at the eaves and valleys. Terra Nova Roofing & Construction installs synthetic underlayment on every roof replacement, plus ice & water barrier at the eaves and valleys. Call or text 973-200-1617 for a free inspection.
What roof underlayment does
Backup against wind-driven rain
Rain blown sideways can get under shingle edges. Underlayment keeps it off the deck.
Protection from ice dams
Water backing up behind ice at the eaves gets under the shingles. Ice & water barrier seals around the nails there.
Dry-in during installation
Once the deck is covered, the house is protected while the shingles go on.
A clean surface for shingles
It separates the shingles from the wood deck and helps them lie flat.
Synthetic underlayment vs. roofing felt
| Synthetic | Felt (tar paper) | |
|---|---|---|
| Material | Woven or spun polymer sheets | Paper or fiberglass mat soaked in asphalt |
| Weight | Light; long rolls | Heavier; shorter rolls |
| Tearing | Resists tearing in wind and foot traffic | Can tear and wrinkle, especially when wet |
| Wet weather | Doesn't soak up water | Can absorb moisture and wrinkle under shingles |
| Walking surface | Many have a textured, slip-resistant surface | Can be slippery when wet |
Both are still used. Terra Nova uses synthetic underlayment as standard on every roof replacement. Always follow the shingle manufacturer's requirements for the underlayment under their product.
Ice & water barrier: where it belongs
Ice & water barrier is a self-adhering membrane that sticks directly to the deck and seals around the nails that go through it. That's what makes it different from regular underlayment. In New Jersey it belongs:
- At the eaves, where ice dams form and water backs up
- In valleys, where two slopes send a lot of water to one line
- Around chimneys, skylights and walls, as an extra layer under the flashing
- On low-slope sections where shingles are allowed but water moves slowly
Your local building code sets minimum requirements, and the shingle manufacturer has its own. Many older roofs in North Jersey have no ice barrier at all, which is why ice-dam leaks are so common. See ice dam roof leaks.
How underlayment is installed, step by step
Tear off to the deck
All old shingles and underlayment come off so the deck can be checked. See why we don't roof over.
Repair the deck
Rotted or soft wood is replaced. Underlayment can't fix a bad deck. See roof deck rot repair.
Drip edge and ice barrier
Drip edge at the eaves, then ice & water barrier at the eaves, valleys and around penetrations.
Underlayment over the rest
Rolled out in overlapping rows from the bottom up, so water runs over each seam, not into it, and fastened per the manufacturer.
Flashing and shingles
Flashing is tied in over the underlayment, then the shingles go on.
Common underlayment installation mistakes
- Laps running the wrong way, so water runs into a seam instead of over it.
- Too little overlap at seams and ends.
- No ice & water barrier at the eaves, or barrier that stops short of the warm wall line.
- Wrinkles and bubbles that show through the shingles.
- Left exposed too long before shingles go on, against the manufacturer's limits.
- Not tied into flashing at walls, chimneys and skylights, so water gets behind it.
- Installed over a wet or rotted deck.
Several of these are behind leaks on brand-new roofs. See new roof leaking after replacement.
Vapor barriers and house wrap: how they're different
| Layer | Where it goes | What it does |
|---|---|---|
| Roof underlayment | On the roof deck, under shingles | Keeps outside water off the deck |
| Vapor barrier / retarder | Usually on the warm side of insulation | Slows moisture from inside the house getting into walls or the roof |
| House wrap | On the outside of wall sheathing, under siding | Keeps rain that gets behind siding off the walls while letting moisture out |
Putting a vapor barrier in the wrong place can trap moisture, so it depends on the roof and attic design. Most attic moisture problems are better solved with ventilation and air sealing. See roof ventilation and siding.
Underlayment on repairs and flat roofs
On a repair, new underlayment goes in only where shingles are removed, and it has to be woven into the old layers so water still runs over every seam. That's one reason a good repair takes more care than just swapping shingles.
Flat and low-slope roofs work differently: the membrane itself (EPDM, TPO or modified bitumen) is the waterproof layer, installed over insulation and a cover board instead of shingle underlayment. See flat roof leak repair.
What to look for in your roofing quote
Underlayment is easy to cut corners on because you'll never see it. Ask:
- Is it a full tear-off to the deck?
- Which underlayment, synthetic or felt?
- Where does ice & water barrier go, and how far up from the eaves?
- Is new drip edge included?
- How is rotted decking priced?
Compare quotes line by line with our roof estimate checklist.
What homeowners say about us
★★★★★ 5-star rated on Google
Get a Free Roof Inspection and Estimate
Tell us about your roof and send any quotes you're comparing. We'll inspect the roof and give you a written estimate that spells out every layer.
Why homeowners call us
- Comparing roof replacement quotes
- Leaks at the eaves in winter
- New roof that leaks
- Wrinkles showing through new shingles
- Want to know what's under the roof
Request your free estimate
Fill this out and a member of our team will follow up within one business day.
✓ No-obligation quote · ✓ Licensed & insured · ✓ Your info is never shared
Questions About Roof Underlayment
What is roof underlayment?
A water-resistant layer installed over the roof deck under the shingles. It keeps water that gets under the shingles off the wood.
Do I need roof underlayment?
Yes. Every shingle roof needs underlayment, plus ice & water barrier at the eaves and valleys.
Is synthetic underlayment better than felt?
Synthetic is lighter, resists tearing and doesn't soak up water. We use synthetic on every roof replacement.
What is ice and water barrier?
A self-adhering membrane that sticks to the deck and seals around nails, used at eaves, valleys and around chimneys and skylights.
Where should ice and water barrier go?
At least at the eaves and in valleys, plus around penetrations and on low-slope areas. Code and the manufacturer set minimums.
What are common underlayment mistakes?
Laps running the wrong way, too little overlap, no ice barrier at the eaves, wrinkles, and not tying it into the flashing.
Is a vapor barrier the same as underlayment?
No. Underlayment keeps outside water out; a vapor barrier slows indoor moisture. Putting one in the wrong place can trap moisture.
What is house wrap?
A layer on the outside of the walls, under siding, that keeps rain off the walls while letting moisture escape.
Can underlayment be replaced without a new roof?
Not really. It's under the shingles, so it's replaced when the roof is.
Is the inspection free?
Yes. The on-site inspection and written estimate with photos are free.
Are you licensed?
Yes. Terra Nova Roofing & Construction is licensed and insured, NJ Lic. #13VH13824700, locally owned in Garfield, NJ.
¿Hablan español?
Sí, hablamos español. Llame o mande texto al 973-200-1617.
Our service area
Bergen County
973-200-1617- Allendale
- Bergenfield
- Bogota
- Carlstadt
- Cliffside Park
- Closter
- Cresskill
- Demarest
- Dumont
- East Rutherford
- Edgewater
- Elmwood Park
- Emerson
- Englewood
- Englewood Cliffs
- Fair Lawn
- Fairview
- Fort Lee
- Franklin Lakes
- Garfield
- Glen Rock
- Hackensack
- Harrington Park
- Hasbrouck Heights
- Haworth
- Hillsdale
- Ho-Ho-Kus
- Leonia
- Little Ferry
- Lodi
- Lyndhurst
- Mahwah
- Maywood
- Midland Park
- Montvale
- Moonachie
- New Milford
- North Arlington
- Northvale
- Norwood
- Oakland
- Old Tappan
- Oradell
- Palisades Park
- Paramus
- Park Ridge
- Ramsey
- Ridgefield
- Ridgefield Park
- Ridgewood
- River Edge
- River Vale
- Rochelle Park
- Rutherford
- Saddle Brook
- Saddle River
- South Hackensack
- Teaneck
- Tenafly
- Teterboro
- Upper Saddle River
- Waldwick
- Wallington
- Washington Township
- Westwood
- Woodcliff Lake
- Wood-Ridge
- Wyckoff
Passaic County
973-200-1617- Bloomingdale
- Clifton
- Haledon
- Hawthorne
- Little Falls
- North Haledon
- Passaic
- Paterson
- Pompton Lakes
- Prospect Park
- Ringwood
- Totowa
- Wanaque
- Wayne
- West Milford
- Woodland Park
Essex County
973-200-1617- Belleville
- Bloomfield
- Caldwell
- Cedar Grove
- East Orange
- Essex Fells
- Fairfield
- Glen Ridge
- Irvington
- Livingston
- Maplewood
- Millburn
- Montclair
- Newark
- North Caldwell
- Nutley
- Orange
- Roseland
- Short Hills
- South Orange
- Verona
- West Caldwell
- West Orange
Hudson County
973-200-1617Union County
973-200-1617- Berkeley Heights
- Clark
- Cranford
- Elizabeth
- Fanwood
- Garwood
- Hillside
- Kenilworth
- Linden
- Mountainside
- New Providence
- Plainfield
- Rahway
- Roselle
- Roselle Park
- Scotch Plains
- Springfield
- Summit
- Union
- Westfield
Morris County
973-200-1617Updated November 2026 by the Terra Nova Roofing & Construction team, Garfield, NJ • NJ Lic. #13VH13824700

